After Set Aside: Why the 45-Day Limit in Consumer Cases Still Bars Filing
When a consumer forum proceeds against an opposite party in its absence and passes an , the opposite party's first instinct is often to get the order set aside and then file its defence. This raises a critical practical question: whether the opposite party can file a written statement or version after the period of limitation, once the in a consumer case is set aside. The short answer, established by binding authority and consistent Commission rulings, is generally no — the 45-day window does not revive.
The Statutory 45-Day Framework
Under (now ), the opposite party must file its within 30 days of receiving notice accompanied by the complaint, extendable by a further period not exceeding 15 days granted by the Commission. Once this lapses without a , the forum may , and the right to file the stands forfeited 2020 2 Supreme 410 and 2025 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 37234.
The 's Verdict: The Limit Is Mandatory
The Constitution Bench of the in settled the position that the time limit prescribed for filing the response to the complaint under Section 13(2)(a) is 2020 0 Supreme(SC) 234. The Court reasoned that the legislative mandate of 30 days plus 15 days was inserted to ensure speedy trial and disposal of consumer disputes within 3 to 5 months 2020 0 Supreme(SC) 234.
Earlier, in , the had held that consumer fora have no power to extend the period for filing the beyond the statutory period of 45 days 2026 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 1152.
Does Setting Aside the Revive the Right?
This is the crux of the issue. An ex parte order can ordinarily be set aside on grounds of — the remedy recognized under , with a separate limitation of 30 days under 2020 0 Supreme(SC) 234 and 2012 0 Supreme(Raj) 586. But that remedy addresses only the ex parte proceeding itself; it does not restore the to file a belated .
The has affirmed that the statutory for filing a written reply is absolute and cannot be extended, noting that unlike other provisions of the Act, Section 38 provides no discretionary power to in filing the reply
Sanjiv Haribhakti VS Prakash Chandra Talati - Consumer (2026)
. Setting aside the allows the opposite party to participate in the proceedings on merits — but through and written arguments on the existing record, not through a fresh .How Commissions Have Applied These Principles
Recent decisions illustrate the boundary clearly:
- Where the was filed only after the expiry of the statutory period, the Commission held that when the Act contains an in-built time-limit for filing the response, allowing an additional after its expiry is impermissible 2025 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 38775.
- Where an ex parte order was set aside during the COVID-19 pandemic, the written statement could be accepted only because the had not yet expired
Chitra Mohan Naik VS Sanjay Wamanrao Chaudhri - Consumer (2026)
. - Where a debarred an opposite party from filing its after the period lapsed, the confirmed there was no error, applying Shrinath Chaturvedi, and further held that cannot be construed liberally where negligence, inaction, or lack of bonafides are attributable to the party 2026 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 1152.
- Conversely, where a forum set a party ex parte before the statutory period expired, appellate and revisional courts intervened, holding such premature ex parte proceedings unsustainable
Rajendra Prasad Centre for Ophthalmic Sciences, AIIMS VS Julius Kachhap
.
Notably, some State Commissions, while setting aside an ex parte order on , have granted liberty to file the version within the statutory period 2026 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 5940 and 2025 Supreme(Online)(SCDRC) 22396 — a formulation that itself confirms that only the unexpired statutory period, not a renewed one, is available.
Pleadings Versus Arguments: What Natural Justice Requires
Opposite parties sometimes argue that refusing to accept a belated violates natural justice. The Commission's answer is that the are satisfied by allowing the opposite party to appear and argue orally, not by permitting a delayed
Sanjiv Haribhakti VS Prakash Chandra Talati - Consumer (2026)
. The in Hilli Multipurpose observed that the legislature was conscious that a complaint could be decided ex parte if no response was filed within time, and in such a case the opposite party will not be allowed to take the plea that it was not given sufficient time or that were not complied withSanjiv Haribhakti VS Prakash Chandra Talati - Consumer (2026)
.There is, however, one safeguard: a filed after the expiry of the period cannot be taken on record, but this does not prejudice the opposite party's future defence through oral submissions in the consumer complaint 2021 0 Supreme(Del) 1724.
Key Takeaways
- The (30 + 15 days) for filing the is mandatory; no , , or can extend it, even by a single day
Branch Manager, Andhra Bank VS Paramkusham VM Pradeep - Consumer (2024)
. - Setting aside an under permits the opposite party to rejoin the proceedings orally but does not revive the right to file a belated .
- The limitation for applying to set aside an ex parte order (typically 30 days) is separate from and additional to the for the .
- Timely filing of the — ideally with the vakalatnama — remains the only safe course for opposite parties.
The outcome in any particular case can depend on the stage of proceedings, the conduct of the parties, and the specific orders passed, so parties facing an should seek advice tailored to their facts.
#ConsumerProtection #ExParteDecree #WrittenStatement #NCDRC #ConsumerLaw